Is there a "Behavioral Psychosis"?
Venugopal D, Murali N, Jagadisha.
Department of Psychiatry, Kasturba Medical College, MANIPAL-576119, INDIA
Classificatory systems which are presently in vogue describe a psychotic person as having ‘hallucinations, delusions and a limited number of several abnormalities of behavior such as gross excitement and overactivity, marked psychomotor retardation, and catatonic behavior’ (ICD-10, 1992). Clinical practice, however, bears testimony to the fact that there exist a large number of patients who do not report/exhibit the above characteristics, and yet are diagnosed to be ‘psychotic’ and improve with antipsychotic medications. A typical presentation of such a patient who does not overtly manifest classical psychotic features, but is still clinically considered as psychotic could be as follows:
A Typical case
The patient presents with a subacute/insidious onset of illness of more than 6 months duration and behavioral abnormalities like:
Patients with the above symptom constellation may at best be classified as suffering from ‘unspecified non-organic psychosis’ according to (International Classification of Diseases, tenth edition) ICD-10, which is virtually a "ragbag" diagnosis. They constitute a significant proportion of psychiatric out patient clinic attenders, and yet, we know precious little about the epidemiology, course, outcome and appropriate management of the syndrome. We suggest the term ‘Behavioral Psychosis’ (pending resolution of its nosological status) for the above constellation of signs and symptoms because ‘psychosis’ is being inferred from the patient’s ‘behavior’ alone and not from the perceptual or cognitive experiences. We hope that this would encourage further research in to the course, outcome and management of this syndrome. This is all the more important because presently, these patients are being managed only on an empirical basis. This syndrome cannot be classified into any specific diagnostic category like schizophrenia, affective disorders, delusional disorder or schizotypal disorder according to ICD-10. It comes close to the ICD-10 description of simple schizophrenia, but differs from the latter by not being "uncommon" and by the presence of some "soft psychotic" features (suggestive of disturbances in reality testing) as described above.
A considerable number of patients present with this ‘syndrome’ of ‘behavioral psychosis’ to mental hospitals in South India. It is not clear as to whether a similar syndrome occurs in other parts of the world. Therefore there is a need for research on the existence and validity of this syndrome so as to provide insights into the course and outcome of the syndrome and an appropriate plan of management.
International Classification of Diseases (ICD)- 10th edition. World health Organization; 1992: Geneva.
Dr. D.Venugopal, Assistant Professor, Department of Psychiatry, Kasturba Medical College, Manipal-576119, India
Tel:0091-8252-71201, Fax No.: 0091-8252-70061